Elden Ring: Nightreign
All Reviews
Action RPG·PCPS5Xbox

Elden Ring: Nightreign

"FromSoftware does it again. Brutal, brilliant, unmissable."

9.4
FromSoftware
May 2025

Nightreign is FromSoftware at their most confident — a relentless expansion of the Elden Ring universe that doubles down on everything that made the original great and strips away the fat.

FromSoftware has never been a studio that rests. Elden Ring: Nightreign arrives less than two years after the base game's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC, and it arrives swinging.

The core loop is familiar — explore, die, learn, conquer — but Nightreign wraps it in a new day/night structure that fundamentally changes how you approach the open world. During the day, you gather resources and scout. At night, the world becomes genuinely hostile in ways the base game never attempted.

Boss design is the headline. Every major encounter in Nightreign feels handcrafted with a level of intentionality that shames most of the genre. The new Nightlord bosses in particular are some of the finest FromSoftware has ever produced — demanding, readable after enough attempts, and deeply satisfying to finally crack.

The build system has been expanded meaningfully. New weapon categories, a revised Ash of War system, and a handful of new status effects give theorycrafters plenty to work with. We spent 80 hours and still hadn't exhausted the viable build space.

It's not flawless. Base PS5 performance was rough at launch — frame drops in dense areas were frequent enough to be genuinely disruptive. And if you're hoping FromSoftware finally made their questlines legible, look elsewhere. The cryptic NPC storylines remain as deliberately obscure as ever.

But these are minor complaints against a game that represents the absolute peak of its genre. Nightreign is mandatory.

The Good

  • +Masterfully designed boss encounters
  • +New night cycle mechanic adds genuine tension
  • +Best-in-class environmental storytelling
  • +Exceptional build variety and weapon depth

The Bad

  • −Performance issues on base PS5 at launch
  • −Some recycled enemy types from the base game
  • −Cryptic questlines remain frustratingly opaque
The Verdict

"FromSoftware does it again. Brutal, brilliant, unmissable."

9.4